By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Destructoid suspends writer for outing scam artist as transgendered

Tagged games:

I don't think I've seen this story discussed here at all, and it's a pretty complicated one but here's a summary of events:

1. Homesick developer Chloe Sagal starts a crowdfunding campaign on Indiegogo to raise money for a "life saving operation" to, supposedly, remove a piece of shrapnel from a car accident that was going to kill her with metal poisoning. (Yes, her lie really was this stupid.) She raised her goal ($35,000) only to have the campaign taken down by Indiegogo twice for fraud.

2. At some point Sagal begins talking to Destructoid's Allistair Pinsof online and confesses to him that she is a male who only presents as female at home and is actually trying to raise the money for sex reassignment surgery. She also attempts to commit suicide, but Pinsof and some others talk her down and she goes to the hospital. Sagal threatens suicide if Pinsof says what he knows, so he keeps it quiet.

3. Sagal later posts a suicide letter on a forum and attempts to commit suicide on Twitch TV, anyway. She survives and winds up in the hospital (again). Despite being warned not to do so by Destructoid, Pinsof tells everything he knows about the story on Twitter.

4. A massive shitstorm erupts because of the "outing" (when Sagal's transgendered status was pretty obvious to anyone with functioning eyes and ears). Pinsof is now suspended by Destructoid and will no doubt be fired.

What say you, Chartz? Is it a journalist's (even a lowly games "journalist") responsibility to tell the whole truth or to keep confidential such information when the initial Indiegogo campaign was kind of a big story on gaming websites? Should Pinsof have told what he knew about the scam but kept the exact nature of the deception to himself? Is Destructoid doing the right thing by standing up for a marginalized community, or is this a craven attempt to deflect the heat from themselves? How many questions can I cram into one post? (Five.)



Around the Network

How could anyone believe she was female? Do u have a link to the IndieGogo video?



Slimebeast said:
How could anyone believe she was female? Do u have a link to the IndieGogo video?

I don't know if it's archived anywhere. Indiegogo removed the whole page.



Yeah read about this on GAF, didn't know what to make of this at first, but after reading it a few times I've come to the conclusion that Alistair should not be fired.

As a gaming journalist it is/was his job to report the truth and as accurate as possible.

I have no problems with transsexuals at all, more power to them for trying to be/become who they feel they should've been born as.

But Chloe Sagal is a fraud and a cheat, she/he tried to blackmail a person as well as lying to people to try to get their money.

If she/he had just been completely honest she/he would've probably gotten the money aswell, hell I'd probably have donated a bit.



What a horrible con man, this politically correct shit is ruining everything for everyone just look at Fallon Fox, but you can't talk bad about them because then you are a transgenderphobe.



Around the Network
Proclus said:

If she/he had just been completely honest she/he would've probably gotten the money aswell, hell I'd probably have donated a bit.

Yeah, I thought so, too. Shit, it's such a trendy thing to do nowadays that it probably would have raised even more money, sadly.



Outside what the scam artist did. I don't have any problem with what any of them did.



ClassicGamingWizzz said:
he did nothing wrong IMO, why fired over this :S

thanks badgenome , that gaf thread was so unreadable xD

Yeah, it's really a continuation of the previous thread.



I'm sorry, but I do not get the whole situation about the writer being fired very clearly (like when he knew about the secret)... O.o



 And proud member of the Mega Mario Movement!

i read about her indiegogo project being removed over in eurogamer, and some people in the comments already talked about her being transsexual and only raising money for the op.

besides, she had put him in a terrible moral position where he didn't have much of a choice.



“It appeared that there had even been demonstrations to thank Big Brother for raising the chocolate ration to twenty grams a week. And only yesterday, he reflected, it had been announced that the ration was to be reduced to twenty grams a week. Was it possible that they could swallow that, after only twenty-four hours? Yes, they swallowed it.”

- George Orwell, ‘1984’