By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Slownenberg said:

Mario Kart could be considered for sure but it's also got a lot of critiques for Nintendo not doing the open world design well. Can a stalwart of Nintendo's best IP be considered a must-have game when it seems to be fairly widely regarded as Nintendo having kinda screwed up on it?? I dunno, but doesn't seem to have the presence and popularity of MK8D. At best sure you could say S2 had precisely one game with MKW, but given the critiques it's not a terribly strong argument.

"Critiques" = I don't play the game, but I crap all over a 'badly designed' open world. Really, it baffles me. If the base of the game was not  RACING, I could see some point towards these critics. But it is NOT THE CASE. It is a racing game, with an open world added as bonus. And, without it, Knockout Tour would not be possible as it is. It also plays superbly, responds very well to commands. It is fun. Has way better physics than previous releases. Is easy to grasp but has a ton to master, making it also a skill based game, not only an item management one. And it is different from the predecessor (which does not play as well in terms of control, feel and physics).

But then again MKW is not a direct follow up to MK8. And the regular Joe usually just wants more of the same. Had it been a safe, direct sequel to the previous iteration, there would be nothing to say was 'screwed up', and most people would be happy.

Thank goodness Nintendo exists, giving us things we never knew we wanted but then showing us we needed them. MKW, without a proper DLC, gave me way more fun than MK8 ever did or could, especially with those gimmicky boost mechanics.

Last edited by farlaff - on 09 November 2026