curl-6 said:
Slownenberg said:
Well by must-have I meant big AAA releases that are system sellers. Pokopia solid sales bump in March or whenever but is a little side pokemon game. Nobody is saying "ya gotta spend $500 to play Pokopia" haha. Switch Sports Resort may sell well but there was zero sales bump and also definitely does not come close to being a must-have game. Nobody is buying S2 for Switch Sports like how EVERYONE was buying the Wii for Wii Sports. Mario Kart could be considered for sure but it's also got a lot of critiques for Nintendo not doing the open world design well. Can a stalwart of Nintendo's best IP be considered a must-have game when it seems to be fairly widely regarded as Nintendo having kinda screwed up on it?? I dunno, but doesn't seem to have the presence and popularity of MK8D. At best sure you could say S2 had precisely one game with MKW, but given the critiques it's not a terribly strong argument. We each have our own opinions of course, but I think there are a lot of people who have been waiting for Switch 2 to actually start getting big must-have games, and OoT really is the first instance of this. Even though it's just an N64 remake, the OoT pedigree seems to be strong enough to made the gaming community look up and be like oh Switch 2 finally has something big on it! I'm starting to see people/websites finallyyyy more broadly admit this online - that the games have been lacking on Switch 2 so far. I think they finally feel okay admitting it because they can point to OoT now and say look it's no longer the case, there is one must have game haha, whereas before they just felt the need to defend Nintendo since the lack of big games criticism was very on point. Must-have System sellers are must-have system sellers for a reason. Especially with how overly expensive systems are now, it's nice for people when they try to make a buying decision of $500 or so to say oh I MUST HAVE this game, it's a game everyone is buying the system for, and that's the reason to shell out a ton of money. OoT really is the first game on the system that seems to be at that level. Switch had it from day 1 with BotW (and a lot more that first year), S2 has been waiting all this time for OoT as its first really major game. S2 hasn't been getting this sort of buzz since the launch hype faded away in summer of last year. |
Actually a lot of people did buy a Switch 2 to play Pokopia: https://nintendoeverything.com/pokemon-pokopia-sales-uk/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2026/04/23/companies/nintendo-pokopia-popularity/ https://www.vgchartz.com/article/467613/switch-2-sales-jump-due-to-pokopia-americas-hardware-estimates-for-march-2026/ For many, Pokopia was clearly a must-have. "AAA" games are not the only ones that people see as must-haves. As for Mario Kart, it's the highest selling game on the platform and has a 62% attach rate, so evidently it's also one of the primary reasons to own the console. Ocarina is not remotely the first system seller the console has had. The biggest perhaps, but not the first, or even the second. |
I don't think you guys are far apart in your argument.
For one, OoT definitely has a massive pull which is something a lot of Switch 2 games lately have been missing. In terms of Nostalgia invoking, it probably is the biggest game in modern times, something that both old heads like myself gravitate to, and what I find fascinating is that it can invoke nostalgia to people who haven't even played it! It's just one of those games that is so important in video game history. I'm not surprised to see it have this impact at all. I think many would agree that this is the purest form of Zelda. From that perspective, yes it is the first must have game for many many people at least since launch.
That said the Switch 2 has had a lot of good AA games, that has kept it ticking. Some games like Pokopia, Splatoon Raiders and Fire Emblem are all performing very well. Add to that the solid third party support, MKW and DK and while you've had a system that hasn't been releasing "must haves", has been a solid system acting as a good cheaper alternative. What I'm saying is that people will buy a console for a library, there's always a game or two that sways a decision towards that, but it takes many games to convince most people. Nintendo have done a solid job at that, and for those who were on the fence, OoT is going to be a major driver.