By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

It's crazy to think we're already in the "spooky" month (i.e. October). In honor of this haunted season, I say it's time we address an elephant in the room: Luigi's Mansion 4. Everyone's always talking about the next 3D Mario and Smash Bros, but I never hear discussion around LM4 despite being of somewhat comparable popularity.

Each entry does things vastly different from the other. The OG focuses on a small handful of gameplay mechanics over a modest, 6-10hr playtime. Dark Moon gets a little more creative in its gameplay mechanics, yet manages this by enforcing a more missions-based structure. The third entry then goes overboard with new ideas, refining many of the ideas from Dark Moon, abandoning the missions-based structure though not fully returning to the structure of the OG (which felt a bit more open-ended IMO).

All that being said... What do you want from Luigi's Manions 4? Would you simply be pleased by a spooky atmosphere closer that of the OG? Are you wanting something bigger, i.e. a bit less arcade-y? Would you want a more open-ended experience, or do you prefer to have your hand held through a 10-hour linear romp?