If you had to choose between only playing games you have already played and only playing games you have never played, what would you choose?

[Shadow1980]

I'd stick with what I'm familiar with. I already know I like those games, and I'm willing to replay a good chunk of them on the regular, especially older games because of the lower time investment needed for a single playthrough. Conversely, with games I haven't played, I have no idea what I'll like or dislike, plus it means giving up on all of the games that are already my all-time favorites without knowing if I'll find any games that I'll like as much as those.