By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Cerebralbore101 said:
BraLoD said:

Even if he was made on top of the actual Lucario 3D model I still would disagree with you. Looking at it doesn't make me thing about Lucario at all, it makes me think about Anubis and Egypy, that design is 100% ok.

Edit: @Cerebralbore101 just saw your reply, take the above as my reply to you too, but I'll add a little more, Anubis like many other mythological figures has countless different interpretations and I can find many different ways it is depicted in modern fantasy that match the Palworld design very well, the clothes, the accesories, all of it is designed to make it resemble Egypt and Anubis and I wouldn't even think about Lucario without you guys telling me.

Unlike with what we see going on with the game in this thread, it immediatly makes me think of the exact figures they are clearly ripping off.

So even if they went into 3DS Max and traced over Lucario's model, that is okay in your eyes? By that logic, I should be able to rip Scorpion's sprite from MK3, change the color palette, so he's wearing a dark brown costume, and it's not ripping anything off. Right? And I should be able to take Snake from MGS3, change his texture colors to pink, give him a sombrero, and that's okay too, right? 

https://www.copyright.gov/engage/visual-artists/ According to this video, sculptures and 3D models are protected under copyright law. 

They can use anything as a base as long as the product they are selling does not use code they don't own or designs they didn't create. They created their own design, it looks like what it was supposed to look, so unless Gamefreak code is being used by them, that is completely okay, yes.

Nothing about that makes me think about Lucario, they clearly weren't trying to ripoff Lucario image, or failed terribly at it, if even a fan since gen 1 like me doesn't think that it evokes it at a first glance.

When I look at this trailer however I can clearly see Charizard, Pikachu, Meganium, and many more, for example, that was clearly made with the intent of ripoff their images. Those things are completely different, IMO.

Inspiration or using other stuff as base is completely normal and everyone does it, Gamefreak has a lot of inspiration on the work of others as well.