Where do I even begin?
Well, I'd say my two favorites are a pair of nostalgic romances actually: Butterfly Soup, which is really the best yuri game I've ever played, would top the list, followed by Gone Home because it's just been my default comfort game when life gets especially stressful for a long time. Other top-ranking choices include...
-Perfect Tides (my favorite choose-your-own-adventure)
-Undertale (my favorite RPG)
-Freedom Planet 2 (the best "Sonic" game ever, IMO)
-Sea of Stars
-Misericorde (both volumes)
-Butterfly Soup 2
-Celeste
-Portal 2
-Crypt of the NecroDancer
-1000xRESIST
-Spiritfarer
-Split Fiction
-It Takes Two
-Kentucky Route Zero
-Both Hollow Knight games (probably the best Metroidvanias ever made)
-What Remains of Edith Finch
-Hades
-Laika: Aged Through Blood
...and I think I'll stop there so it doesn't get too unwieldy. Though it's incomplete as yet, Deltarune is also in the running, I feel obliged to add.
