Currently Online 
It's the Super NES I think. People aren't properly accounting for not only the 3rd party games it had but also the fact that many of them were exclusive to the SNES.
Street Fighter II on the SNES isn't just "ho hum, a fun game to play!" ... you're talking about the biggest 3rd party game of that time, it would be like the Switch 2 getting GTA VI exclusive in its first year.
Super Mario World
Pilotwings
F-Zero
Sim City
Mario Paint
Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Super Scope 6
Street Fighter II
Castlevania IV
Contra III
Final Fantasy IV
Actraiser
Top Gear
Super Adventure Island
Super R-Type
John Madden Football
Ninja Turtles: Turtles In Time, Super Ghouls N' Ghosts, The Legend of the Mystical Ninja, Joe & Mac, Romance of the Three Kingdoms II, etc. also.
Super Mario Kart also just misses the cut off here by like a week, it release Sept. 1, 1992 which was just barely a year over the Aug. 23, 1991 SNES release date. That's so close I almost consider it a first year game.
