I love both personally, and find both far superior to aiming with an analogue stick, but if I had to choose one, the pointer is just faster and more accurate.
The kind of snappy pinpoint aiming you get in something like Sin and Punishment, Metroid Prime 3/Trilogy, or RE4 Wii Edition is just on another level.
That said, gyro can still be great, and its implementation greatly elevated games like Sniper Elite for me.







