What is your guy's favorite controller?
This might be unpopular but my favorite controller is the Wii U gamepad, it was surprisingly super comfortable for me to use as my main controller despite being so large, the handlebars of the Wii U gamepad felt finely-tuned for comfort. I have larger hands so that's probably why I liked the controller the best.
The NES controller has good feeling buttons but the controller felt too small. The SNES controller feels comfortable for 2D games, much better controller shape than the NES with the rounded edges and was big enough to feel more comfortable. The N64 controller isn't as uncomfortable as it looks but it just feels too unconventional to be considered very comfortable for me. The Gamecube controller is widely regarded as one of, if not the best controller of all time, and while I remember loving the controller in the past, I notice that as I got older and my hands started getting larger the controller just feels a bit too small for my liking, it's still a comfortable controller overall, just not amazing to me like it used to be. I hated the Wii remote to be honest, playing with it sideways and/or with a nunchuck would always feel awkward and uncomfortable. The Switch joycons IMO are also too small.
