Yes and no.
The added previous experience that permits someone to already a game and it's foundation is always a net positive in my book when it comes to.e to make the comparison list and see what was upgraded or changed for the worst.
Yet, there's no fault in simply having a fresh and new perspective from someone who has not played the prior original before(aside from a bit of web osmosis).
Though at worst you might look like the original goofy IGN reviewer of Xenoblade Chronicles Definitive Edition xD
Switch Friend Code : 3905-6122-2909