Alien 3 by quite a bit. I mean, it wasn't great, but it did have the basic Alien formula worked out okay. And I rather like the ending.
Other than Sigourney Weaver's impossible basketball shot that turned out to be real I dont see anything interesting or redeeming in Resurrection. Even Ron Perlman's usual charisma is missing. Story/plot is non existant. Dialogue is dumb. Characters are cardboard. Winona's acting is abysmal. I dont know, Its the worst Alien film so far to me - even Alien V Predator 1 was more interesting. Its close to "its so bad its funny" territory. That alien-human hybrid? Terrible.
Alien 3 was not good and while it did shit on the ending of Aliens, which Is its biggest mistake IMO, at least it build a good atmosphere and kept some of the tension that I feel Alien films should have. Needless to say, Resurrection had none of it.
It also gave us this iconic scene, which is great.
