Super Metroid is probably my top seed. I had been gaming for a decade when it came out. But, it was the first game that really sucked me in. All day at school I would count the hours until I could get home and play. And, as others have said, its just an all around great game.
If we take sentimentality out of it, BotW is probably the more objective winner. I will note that the DLC for BotW was disapointing, and probably actually detracts from my love for the game. I'd have preferred not to come back to it for mediocre content that really just tarnished my memories of an otherwise excellent game.








