Always the hardest question in the world. It's like trying to pick a favorite significant other. They all had their highs and lows and in the end in retrospect made you really happy. The fact of the matter, though, is that because the Wii had the Virtual Console and some really amazing games in its own right, it gets my vote. Not all of the games were waggle-based, and many of those that were were really fun. I loved random games like Elebits and Zack and Wiki and Little King's Story, Pikmin received a super fun update, Mario Galaxies were amazing, two Zelda titles, WiiWare, WiiSports, a superior version of Resident Evil 4, Metroid Prime Trilogy with improved aiming, and it played Gamecube games. It really was the rebirth of my favorite company into the hearts and minds of a who new generation of gamers and even managed to reach back in time to grab previous generations. Ok, now I'm just gushing.