| o_O.Q said: A) "It is not dismissing that biology plays some role in various aspects" according to the quote this is in response to if I was a man I could at this moment in time choose to identify as a woman with my penis, my full beard, etc etc etc since " it is hypocritical for any self-identified feminist to use “biology” and “body parts” arguments in their attempts to dismiss trans women" do you agree with that? if not how am I wrong? B) "As such, any assertion by society or even a doctor is typically unable to see the full picture of an individual's biology to make their conclusion." so therefore the only option left is for the person to identify themself as what they are(man, woman, sheep, ox, lion, etc etc etc), regardless of biology since biology is societies way of classifying things? do you agree with that? if not how am I wrong? C) another quote I want your opinion on is this one ""No, Trans Women Are NOT ‘Biologically Male"" D) "I have already defined maleness+femaleness for you" look stop bringing this into this conversation, it has nothing to do with what is being discussed here, the relevant terms here are gender and presumably sex E) "That said, your assumption was ridiculously dumb and unnecessary." well I'm letting go of all of my presumptions when it comes to this topic to understand your perspective, so I let you have free reign with what things mean so i can see where you are going with your reasoning "I think I've told you this before, but you are awful at making assumptions. " as I've repeated just now, you brought these terms that have nothing to do with the topic at hand into discussion about gender so naturally it seemed like you were substituting them in for gender " I am worried about you." I should be worried about you, but all that's left is apathy and a deep deep curiosity |
A) The goalposts seem to be moving. The quote is not dismissing the role of biology but instead contextualizing it, and as such, your initial assertion is incorrect.
B) The goalposts seem to be moving. The quote is not dismissing the role of biology but instead elaborating on it, and as such, your initial assertion is incorrect.
C) Basically the same as "B"
D) No. Maleness and femaleness are fundamental to this discussion. Don't blame me that you can't keep your head on straight when you have to deal with more than two words at a time.
E) Yes, and what better way to "Let go of presumptions" than to ignore most of what I say and make ridiculous assumptions. 10/10 from the German judge.
