By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
sub-zero-TM on 04 July 2019
Edit Thread
vivster said:
sub-zero-TM said:

I think season 2 is more epic than season 1 since it has only 12 episodes it rarely gives us a moment to breathe and of course has one of the most crazy mindblowing moments ever. That being said season 1 is superior cause it has more eps and as you said it's tighter. i rate first two seasons 9/10 , season 3 part 1 8/10 and season 3 part 2 a 10/10.

Be sure to watch it again from the beginning if you plan on catching up cause there are a lot of details and moments in first seasons that are important for season 3 it will be worth it and you will enjoy it more trust me. The only anime i've ever rated a 10/10 was FMAB and now i can safely say that AOT is 10/10 as a whole series.

So what animes are 10/10's in your opinion ?

Have a look.

https://myanimelist.net/animelist/vivster?status=2&order=4&order2=0

Most recently Made in Abyss and Houseki no Kuni, which are complete 10s in every single aspect of production. Basically flawless. AOT has some visible flaws, especially with characters and death trodden shounen tropes. Also pacing is a huge issue. It's a great anime but but I wouldn't call all of its parts perfectly arranged or executed.

Let me just say that rarely anything is 10/10 in my book and nothing is perfect so 10/10 doesn't mean perfection. But thanks to AOT S3 Part 2 it cemented itself as one of the best animes ever just look at the ratings everywhere.. and looking at all the seasons together now it's damn near perfect i mean the amount of work they have put in this anime is crazy ! Plot details that seemed unimportant in first seasons all come back in S3 EVERYTHING get's followed through, the seeds planted and little details sprinkled throughout S1 and 2 amount to shocking and mindblowing moments, GOD animation and action , more serious and higher stakes than ever it was epic and amazingly done that's why i think so highly of it. Mark my words when the final season finishes next year AOT will be remembered as one of the best and legendary animes ever and probably will be the highest rated anime topping FMAB it certainly has the potential for that. :)

I loved Made in Abyss and i can't wait for more. I would maybe give it a light 9/10 there is no way i can give 10/10 to show with only 13 eps and with such little story and also i though it was needlessly brutal and F up not that i mind that kind of stuff or that i don't have the stomach for it (AOT has plenty of that) .. i just thought it didn't fit well with the world and the way characters look and act.