By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
StarOcean said:

This may be the worst nit-picks I've seen for this movie and that's saying something. Like, I've seen bad opinions but this one is really bad.
Also SW "fans" gotta stop worshipping puppets like they're the most amazing thing in the universe. Jesus Christ, you'd think the only thing this fanbase watches outside of SW is the Sesame Street Star Wars Special where puppets are everywhere. We get it, you got raped by CGI in the form of Jar Jar. He got you good in the butthole and now you have a PTSD aversion to them. They aren't bad. CGI is fine. And it definitely wasn't used in a bad way this movie

The rest of your stuff is not really worth even covering since it's just word vomit

ALSO: I'm not pretending the movie is perfect. But none of these were real issues the movie had. There are plenty of glaring issues that were not addressed in this "Top 5"

CGI does not always look better than real.  So, I supposedly worship Sesame Street, because I know that the Return of the Jedi Jabba the Hutt looked 100% more real that the rubbery CGI Jabba that was created years later?  The Grand Moff Tarkin in Rogue One would have looked fine in an animated film like The Polar Express, but looks completely out of place conversing with live actors.  Computer generated is not always better.  There is a reason why the Special Edition Wampa was still a man in a suit.  CGI of living, moving creatures/people in live action films don't blend as well as CGI objects (buildings, space ships, etc).