By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
tbone51 on 13 October 2017
Edit Thread
pokoko said:
TruckOSaurus said:
Not to rain on anyone's parade but a 95+ score is not guaranteed because one usually harsh critic has given the game a perfect score. It's a good sign for sure but let's not get carried away.

I wouldn't even say "usually harsh".  EDGE is infamous for loving certain types of games but low-balling others. 

Whether you "trust" EDGE or not probably depends on what kind of games you like.

Is it because mario (3d) ans zelda have 3 perfect scores people say this? I mean every1 last gen were saying SMG/TLoU are the GoaT (like in agreement) SM64/LoZ OoT are self explanatory. Skyward Sword i can see people getting somewhat worked up over but even that they only gave 20 10/10 scores away.

 

3D Mario Games made: 6 (7 if remake ds counts) and 3 got perfect scores on EDGE.

 

Zelda Games: over 20, 3 of which are perfect scores. (If only 3D zelda then 3 out of 6)

 

I mean are they really infamous for doing that? (I dont kno EDGE too well)