First Super Mario Odyssey Review in! (EDGE)

[Azuren]

Shaunodon said:

Azuren said:

LittleBigPlanet and Skyward Sword? What were they smoking?

 

Although they do have Bloodborne on there. Can't disagree with that. In fact the only titles I disagree with being given 10/10 are LBP, Skyward Sword, and the Devil May Cry clones Bayonetta games. That said, I am curious as to how Halo 1 and 3 made the cut, but not the best (Halo 2).

I'm not sure how much of LBP you actually tried but that game is a legit classic.

Halo 1 pioneered the formula, Halo 2 evolved it, and Halo 3 perfected it. Sounds about right that Halo 2 just misses out.

If anything there were some notable omissions (Red Dead Redemption, Xenoblade, Deus Ex, Metroid Prime, Bioshock all come to mind).

I was super hyped for LBP when it came out, and was thoroughly disappointed.

 

I would argue that Halo 2 perfected everything that needed to b perfected; Halo 3 is where they began to complicate it.

 

And I don't personally believe any of those games are worthy of perfect score, but I could see some people arguing vehemently against that notion. Though truth be told, I have no idea what people see in the Mario games. He jumps on stuff, and he gotten a new gimmick in each new game since 6th Gen (Water Pack in Sunshine, King Kai's planet in Galaxy 1&2, and now hijacking airplanes enemies).