Project Octopath Demo, meh

[Jumpin]

irstupid said:

Jumpin said:

Before I get into the stuff I didn't like, the stuff I did like.

THE GOOD

1. The idea of selecting different characters with different gameplay features and skills.
2. The art style is factastic, reminiscent of late SNES and early Playstation style RPGs with up to date detail.
3. The use of HD rumble feels really great, the feedback is welcomed.
4. The interaction with towns people, using different character abilities.

WHAT I HATE!

The goddam battle system is about the most ridiculously gimmicky battle system I can ever remember coming across in an RPG.

In most RPGs the command to attack is simple, you make sure the cursor is on the Attack command, then you hit A. In this game: First you hit R to charge up your attack (if you don't, you're just wasting attack potential), then you select your proper weapon to make sure to hit the enemy's weakness, and then you hit attack. A little complexity never hurt, right?

WRONG, in this game, you are constantly in battles. Regular battles are long and drawn out, and you'll find yourself doing those same set of commands over and over again, hundreds and hundreds of times during the course of the demo, which is only 2-3 hours. It gets EXTREMELY tiring for anyone who realizes the BS they're going through. It doesn't accomplish anything more than other RPGs, it's a tacked on gimmick to make the attack command take more work top execute than it should need.

"But you can stock attacks for strategically timed bursts" - that is how it is marketed. The reality is in ever single case with the demo, this offered no significant benefit. Essentially, if you hit an enemy once and store the attack to hit him 3 times the next turn, it accomplishes no extra damage than just hitting the enemy twice, and then twice again after. The only time where I saw a benefit is when using a special move, and then following up with a triple hit - but even then, it is a rather trivial addition, and it doesn't improve the gameplay experience.

The battle system was tiring after only one character's demo, I can only imagine how horrendous it will be throughout the entirety of a (presumably) 40-90 hour game that seems to be heavily focused on having lots of long drawn-out random battles.

Never have I been sold and unsold so fast on a game. But I thank Square for putting out the demo so I could find this out now.

I'm going to have to respectfully disagree.

Let's use an example. I'm fighting an enemy and I hit him once and it does damage. He attacks me. My next turn I attack him using 3x and notice on the second hit that I get a break. I just learnt that using that weapon, it takes 3 hits total to set him into break mode. IF you didn't notice, break mode means they lose their turn to not only attack that turn, but the following turn.

Thus I keep that in memory. While he is break mode, I DO NOT use my chain attack, I attack with a normal attack, a magic attack, buff myself, heal, summon ally, whatever. The point is, I build up 1 point for the following turn when he gets to attack again. My turn ends, and its my turn again, due ot him being broke,. He is no longer broke, so he will attack after me. I go to 3X attack, because I KNOW that this will break him. Thus he doesn't get ot attack again.

I've fought so many battles, where th enemy has gotten to attack like once to each of my like 8 turns. Heck, lots of times beyond te first round, the enemy never gets to attack again.

That is how you use the break system, not to just endlessly use as much as you can each round, which would be two. You can go to a max of four, even though you can build up higher than that.

Most enemies break at either 2 or 3. I usually start a battle with a 2x attack. If that don't break them, then i know its 3 and just do a normal attack next round. Then while they are broke I do a simple magic attack that does like 10x the damage of my normal attack. Doing a normal magic attack also builds up a counter, so my next attack, i have 3. Just enough to break again. Rinse and repeat. Enemy dead.

And you can do that way easier by hitting twice each turn and keeping the enemy broken and unable to attack until it is dead.

All you have done is describe a bunch of actions which take more commands to accomplish the exact same simple task of attacking. After you repeat this chore  hundreds and hundreds of times, it gets tiring. There are easier and less painful ways to go about a battle system.