Zelda BOTW has the most perfect scores on Metacritic.

[TheBlackNaruto]

SpokenTruth said:

Game	Platform	Perfect Scores	Total # of Reviews	Lowest Score
LoZ: Ocarina of Time	N64	18	22	90
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2	PS	11	19	90
GTA IV	PS3	37	64	87
LoZ: Breath of the Wild	Switch	45	72	90
Soul Calibur	DC	14	24	88
GTA IV	X360	48	86	80
Super Mario Galaxy	Wii	29	73	90
Super Mario Galaxy 2	Wii	42	87	90
GTA V	XOne	7	14	90
GTA V	PS3	26	50	80
GTA V	X360	35	58	70
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2	DC	6	18	90
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3	PS2	12	34	70
Perfect Dark	N64	12	30	90
GTA V	PS4	33	66	90
Metroid Prime	GC	27	70	80
GTA III	PS2	24	56	80
Halo: Combat Evolved	Xbox	29	68	80
NFL 2K1	DC	7	22	90
Half-Life 2	PC	31	81	85

Currently, GTA IV on the X360 is the single game SKU with the most perfect scores at 48.  LoZ: Breath of the Wild is second at 45 and has a chance to take that lead.  LoZ: Ocarina of Time has the highest percentage of perfect scores with 82% though it is skewed by circumstance.  The highest percentage under the modern era is still a LoZ title.  62.5% of all Breath of the Wild scores are perfect.

I may try combining SKUs but a lot of reviews are copy/paste between platforms so they'd have to be tracked down and added as a single score.

Just curious but I am almost positive that TLOU should be up there right? It definitely got more than 7 perfect scores on PS3. I know for a fact that it is over 40  or was there some other metric for this chart. And UC2 had like what 40? No less that 30 or 35 I am sure. .......Never mind I see it....top 20 highest rated games or fall time