Mafia Round 77 - Low-Power?? Hate the Mod!!

[Final-Fan]

NoCtiS_NoX said:

Final-Fan said:

Don't worry, I didn't forget you.  I just saved the best for last!
-I was really impressed by hatmoza's big data contribution, and correspondingly I didn't think much of padib's reason for dismissing its value.  He said that his lack of interaction with players is due to the fact that he is "calm", which is just mind-boggling in and of itself.  Surely he meant some other thing because calmness has nothing to do with whether or not he interacts with other players in the game.  I called this out. 
-Then he went on the attack against hatmoza and said no one cared about his data. 
-Then he voted TruckOSaurus (pretty much out of nowhere, or so it seemed to me).  He suggested that we "trickle votes in", which made me suspicious that perhaps he was scum who didn't really care who got lynched but just wanted it to be whoever had enough support to accomplish the lynch. 
-Then, after prof voted him, he immediately revenge voted.  I mean if I had more respect for him as a player, I would be more hesitant to consider this a scum tell, but as it stands he's just some guy to me with a textbook scum tell. 

Basically, I completely agreed with prof, so I didn't articulate my own thoughts.  I should have said that much, at the very least.  Whoops. 

The explanation is great but the thing the irks me is when just voted and oozes scum. This could have been on day 1 not day 2. 

You didn't provide any reasoning for your vote. I find it scummy.

I can't go back and fix it, sorry.  All I can say is that even though I didn't say the part about agreeing with prof's reasoning, I had made some other posts about how I thought hatmoza's points were sound and padib's response was garbage.  So I do have at least some evidence for why I was leaning in the same direction for more reason than "oozes scum".  I just didn't recap it in the post where I voted.