Mafia Round 77 - Low-Power?? Hate the Mod!!

[Final-Fan]

spurgeonryan said:

NoCtiS_NoX said:

Care to answer the question of FF?

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8276062

"Only 2 scum in a 12 player game? Why would you expect that to be a serious possibility? FoS spurge."

Here ya go FF. Fuck me that was a waste of a lot of posts from you on the matter. Did you scum hunt or do hardly anything else other than hang onto this? So Noctis thought it was crazy to be two. most likely three he said. STefl thought it was most likely 3, but two a possibility. What do you all think now that we have a load of dead town, what seems_ to be a third party, and whoever else is left?

Okay, I assume this post is in response to the first question I asked in this post:  http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8280264
I'm glad that you admit that Noctis didn't say anything even remotely resembling "three (scum) is rubbish (as a probability in this game)". 

I had other really, really important questions for you in that same post, including one that I've been asking you over and over and over for almost the entire game at this point.  Apparently, though, you have the attention span of a butterfly and drifted off after answering the Noctis question.  Read this very, very carefully, spurge.  I need 100% of your attention right now.  One hundred percent. 

Vote spurgeonryan

Do I have your attention now? 

You said, way back then, this: 

spurgeonryan said:
Wouldn't that be fun if everyone voted no lynch and we seriously did no talking today?
Although I kind of agree, nothing to see today.
What are we all thinking? 2 maybe 3 scum, a doc and a cop and that is it, or a few more? Or few less. I cannot ever remember playing a vanilla game before.

and I said: 

Final-Fan said:
Only 2 scum in a 12 player game? Why would you expect that to be a serious possibility? FoS spurge.

 

When I said this, I did not think that you had said there could only possibly be two scum.  But I did think you had said that two scum was a realistic possibility.  ("Two scum" and "three scum" were both realistic possibilities in your mind.)  My question, the same question I have been trying to get you answer for the entire game, is this:  Why did you suggest there was a realistic possibility of only two scum in a game with twelve players? 

Right now, the best hypothesis I have for why you would think that is you are a serial killer and were thinking "2 maybe 3 OTHER scum".  Convince me that you had a different reason. 

P.S.  Yes, I agree that this has gone on for too long and has taken too much of my attention this game.  Do you know whose fault that is?  It's your fucking fault.  You could have answered this very simple question the first time I asked you, or the second time, or the third time, or the time that Noctis asked you to answer it, and so on.  But instead you have continuously dodged around it, intentionally or unintentionally.  Regarding my pursuit of this topic, if I am a monster then I am one you have created yourself. 

P.P.S.  Just in case you missed it, Why did you suggest there was a realistic possibility of only two scum in a game with twelve players? 
Why did you suggest there was a realistic possibility of only two scum in a game with twelve players? 
Why did you suggest there was a realistic possibility of only two scum in a game with twelve players? 

P.P.P.S.  Could you please point me to the post where Stefl agreed that two scum was a realistic possibility?  I'm about to finally do the full re-read I've been meaning to do, so I may find it myself, but if you find it before I post on the matter I'd appreciate a link or quote.