Would Rare have been better off with Nintendo?

[curl-6]

Ck1x said:

curl-6 said:

I actually think their decline began before they left Nintendo; their final game for Ninty, Starfox Adventures, was pretty bad and lacked the quality of their prior works, impressive graphics aside.

Frankly, I don't think Rare has made a single good game since the N64.

I'm not sure what game you played, yes the game may have been a let down as far as Starfox story franchise goes. But the game definitely wasn't a bad game! 

Even if you took Starfox out of it, it'd still be a poor game in my book. The voice acting was atrocious, the gameplay boring and uninspired, and overall it simply had none of the creativity or charm of Rare's N64 works. About the only good thing about it was its admittedly superb graphics, but all the eye candy in the world can't save a game with weak gameplay.