By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
FaithRaven said:
Mummelmann said:
The idea is great, but BMI really is highly flawed.

Dude doctors are using BMI in population statistics. Don't let you fooled by this people payed to slam Wii Fit. BMI is not exact but it can give you a GOOD idea oh how you are and how do you progress.

If a kid in 2 years gain little height but plenty of pounds his BMI will skyrocket showing the truth (the kid may have got a few muscles but he also got a lot of fat).

I'm not being fooled by anyone, I'm a few months away from my PT license and the general consensus in the fitness industry here is "Do not use BMI". If someone wants me to train them, I measure height, weight and the overall girth and body measures and lastly bodyfat. I see no point in using BMI, and before you say "But those who are not personal trainers!"; using a measure tape and a bodyfat "pincher" (this device is dirt cheap as well) is very simple if you know basic maths and have two fully functional hands and a brain, and it is very precise with a little practise.