Super_Boom on 20 June 2016
I'm not familiar with MAL rankings, but if I had to guess what the highest aggregrate score will be, I'd guess either Jojo, D. Gray Man, or Berserk based on the same reasoning Shadow gave.
People who didn't like the beginning of these anime are less likely to come back and watch/rate them again, and the ones that do like them will rate them highly because they're so hyped up. Not a slight against any of these anime, but I think long-running anime will tend to score more highly for this reason, while new anime will have to try harder to prove themselves.
Still, Versy needs a solid answer, so I'm going to guess Berserk with a 9.08.
NNID: Zephyr25 / PSN: Zephyr--25 / Switch: SW-4450-3680-7334
