IGN gives Wii Fit a 8.0 WOW WHAT HAPPENED to core reviewers these days?

[yushire]

tabsina said:

yushire said:

tabsina said:

yushire said:
^ Most core reviewers says otherwise in Wii Sports and Wii Play though, I even heard in gametrailers that Wii Sports have Nintendo 64 graphics.

that was at wiis launch, gaming websites have matured a lot since then to the concept of casual gaming.. but i don't think they are quite there yet (despite this particular 8 score being pretty fair)

 

If you think that then its like reviewing Mario and Sonic and Carniival games and also give it a 8 even its only a collection of mini games. Core reviewers will have a hard time reviewing casual titles...

 

i'm not sure what you are saying.. but i didn't claim all casual games (or minigame games) should get an 8 out of 10, just that they are learning to score games based on their target.. and i even said that they haven't quite gotten there yet, but its a big improvement since launch of the wii

That said, as you probably (or actually, quite possibly not) know, wii fit is more than a collection of minigames, so i'm not surprised its scoring more than carnival games, for example

 

It still not fair for core reviewers to score carnival games as they did though, just read my last post to know what I mean.