By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
curl-6 said:
Soundwave said:

Wii vs Wii U is interesting I guess.

Hardware

Wii U > Wii (Wii U was a good sized upgrade even if it was still competitively outdated), Wii was a repackaged GameCube basically.

Software

Splatoon > anything new on the Wii
Mario Kart 8 > Mario Kart Wii
Bayonetta 2 = Metroid Prime 3 (the token Nintendo "hardcore" title).
NSMBU > NSMB Wii
Nintendo Land > Wii Sports/Fit (Sports/Fit might be more casual, but NL is the better overall game).
Xenoblade X < Xenoblade Chronicles
Mario 3D World < SMG 1&2
AC Amiibo Fesitval < AC City Folk
Smash U > Smash Wii
DKC: Tropical Freeze > DKC Returns
Mario Maker > any remaining major Wii title

Misc. Nintendo IP ...

Captain Toad + Yoshi's Wooly World + Star Fox 0 + Devil's Third + Pikmin 3 + Wonderful 101, LEGO City
vs
Kirby's Epic Yarn, The Last Story, Excite Truck, Punch-Out!, Endless Ocean 1/2, Sin & Punishment

That's pretty close, I'd say Wii has a small edge here, but Pikmin 3 is probably the best game of that bunch.

Your Wii list is missing Pandora's Tower and Kirby's Return to Dreamland. (Which destroys Rainbow Curse)

Also, Wii had more noteworthy third party exclusives, like Tatsunoko vs Capcom, Little King's Story, de Blob, Sonic Colours, (Which destroys Lost World and Boom) No More Heroes 2, Red Steel 2, etc.

Also, as Einsam rightly points out, Wii had a proper Zelda, Metroid, and an ambitious 3D Mario all in its first 12 months.

Library wise, Wii > Wii U by a signficant margin.

The Wii U quality wise ironically probably as many decent third party games even with just a few months of support, Zombi U, Rayman, Call of Duty: BLOPS 2, Batman Arkham, Need for Speed, Tekken, had a decent start, shame it couldn't sustain itself. 

Of course the Wii should have a better overall library, it had 6 years of support vs. 3 1/2 for the Wii U, but the Wii U isn't even that far off.

The main boom for the Wii was overwhelming market success but by and large what that mostly brought Nintendo fans was crappy third party shovelware and "me-too" fitness/dance soccer mom crap-athons.

Wii's Zelda was ripped off from a GameCube game with controls slapped onto it, remove that and Wii's first year is alright but probably a fair sized step down from the GameCube's first year.

To be honest I think I enjoyed my Wii U more than the Wii. While the two Mario Galaxy games are outstanding achievements, beyond that I found Splatoon, Mario Maker, Mario 3D World as my other favorite games as they're on Wii U. Wii U also has the better Mario Kart and Smash Brothers which is not too shabby. And once you get used to Nintendo games in HD, you never want to go back, gimme HD over waggle any day, it never really added much to things like Mario Galaxy or DKC anyway.

Generally speaking though I won't miss the Wii brand (Wii or Wii U) much at all, did not like this era too much, the Wii U fizzling out completely is just the low point. Much prefer the N64/GCN or NES/SNES eras.