I don't feel like I'm in a position to judge Nurse Witch Komugi-chan R fairly. They changed so much of the show in order to make it a more typical magical girl/idol anime but I, for one, absolutely loved the absurdist humor that it used to have. Beyond that, they replaced the iconic voices of Komugi and Magical Maid in order to make them more normal. Original Magical Maid is like TEN BILLION TIMES better than the new one and new Komugi feels more like "average anime girl A" than the hyper insanity she was before.
On the positive side, Tsukasa is a good addition. However, they got rid of some awesome side characters, like bikini model/rival Megumi and the hilarious little girl idol who hated Komugi's guts.
All of this means there will be no more of Nurse Witch Komugi picking up a roller coaster train loaded with people and hitting Magical Maid Koyori with it while yelling "Dolphin Chop" and that makes me sad.
