What is, in your opinion, the best Mario lineup possible for ONE console generation ?

[AlfredoTurkey]

zorg1000 said:

AlfredoTurkey said:

Sure, if you want to count pre-school, educational bullshit that no one cared or even knew about. I was talking about main games. You know, that people actually paid attention to? That wasn't niche and buried on arrival? So, allow ME to trim your little list down.

1985 - SMB

1988 - SMB2

1990 - SMB3

1991- SMW

1992 - MK

1995 - SMW2

 

That's six titles in 10 years. Mario All Stars is bullshit because it was a port. Since the Wii launched 9 years ago, I can think of 8 major Mario releases NOT including Mario Party, Tennis, Golf or whatever else they have released. If you add those in, holy shit... 

 

 

 

Why does a game like Mario Maker count but Mario Paint doesn't? It's basically a spiritual successor to MP. Also Mario All-stars weren't ports, they were remakes.

 

Mario Maker is actually a brand new concept. I'd put Mario Maker in the same sort of category as say... Paper Mario. All-Stars was just a cart with NES games on it.