Wii was technical superior but not by much. For me it is all about the franchises.
Zelda: Tie- Both had one unique zelda and one that was shared
Metroid: Winner Gamecube- prime 1 and 2 win versus prime 3 and other m
3D mario: Winner wii- galaxy 1 and 2 together easily beat sunshine
2D mario : Winner wii- absent on gc
Smash bro's: Winner Gamecube- prefer melee
F-zero: Winner Gamecube- absent on wii
Mario kart: Tie: mkwii had more tracks and vehicles but mkdd was more fun to play.
Pikmin: winner Gamecube- absent on wii
Starfox: winner Gamecube- absent on wii
Donkey kong: winner Wii- DKCR destroys jungle beat and konga
Poke'mon: Winner Gamecube- colosseum and gale of darkness destroy battle revolution
Paper mario: Winner Gamecube- We all know that TTYD is better than super paper mario.
Fire emblem: Tie- Enjoyed both radiant dawn and path of radiance
Other nintendo franchises: winner Gamecube -the wii brought back excite bike and truck but no waverace, 1080 or chibi robo.
Other RPG's: Winner wii- xenoblade, last story, okami,Tales symphonia 2 and fragile dreams beat Tales of symphonia 1, baten kaitos and lost kingdoms.
Other 3rd party: winner Gamecube- resident evil zero, remake & 4, viewtifuljoe 1 & 2, killer 7, soul calibur 2, prince of persia trilogy, splintercell trilogy, eternal darkness, timesplitters 2 & 3, burnout 2, mgs twin snakes, beyond good and evil, super monkey ball 1 & 2, FF CC beat no more heroes 1 & 2, Sin and punishment SS, red steel 2 and Sonic colours.
I make Gamecube the winner.
