tokilamockingbrd said:
this. The PT films are enjoyable. Are the as good as the Originals. NO!. But that does not prevent them from being fun imaginative film in their own right. Basically each of the 1st 2 have a fatal flaw. EP 1, JAR JAR. Nuff said. EP 2, horrible romantic dialoge. EP 3 is pretty good. My only issue with it is the fight scenes drag. Yes the CGI was overused. But, when they were released people like it. The issue is that now they looked like dated videogames. The CGI does not age well. |
While my opinion of JarJar has changed as I've matured, I found him to be an enjoyable character as a kid actually XD I never liked how he looked though, I just wanted to punch him... and yeah the romance was a bit much in 2. I'd argue that 2 is the worst Star Wars movie since most of the movie is centered around romance and politics, which isn't inheritly bad, but the way it was executed could have been a bit better with a few fight scenes here and there. I think the problem I have most with 2 is that it is incredibly slow compared to every other Star Wars movie. Which is a shame since it shows us the Clone Wars! 3 does a better job at showing it, as did the side shows with it 
and yeah, 3 was good. My only gripe was the battle droids were turned into jokes by the 3rd movie. I never understood why they turned them into comic relief throughout the trilogy, perhaps better AI? Idk
The CGI is a bit bad in some areas. But I'd say it was decent and some of it holds up pretty good. The only place they don't fit is in the OG Trilogy re-releases. I'm not a OG Trilogy fanatic, but the CG they added in don't mesh well with the movies at all :S perhaps if they waited a little longer to improve CG it wouldn't have looked so odd, but because of the time of release it doesn't look right. However that is just my opinion.
