You should buy the console you enjoy the most. Graphics only go so far.
Look at my favorite consoles:
Genesis (weaker than SNES)
PSX (weaker than N64)
Dreamcast/PS2 (weaker than Gamecube/Xbox)
Xbox 360
As far as 1080p, The higher quality the TV and the bigger the screen, the more noticeable a sub 1080p resolution becomes.
If you enjoy the exclusives, and the competitors exclusives aren't of interest, or if you already have the competing products, go for it. If you just care about third party games then go with the PS4. I'm not a fan of the Xbox One's hardwre, or how Microsoft originally handled the Xbox One, but the Forza series alone is reason enough for me to own one. Hope that helps.
"And everyone's Kickstarter has merit." - Malory Archer
