Is "Miitomo" a good idea?

[potato_hamster]

Wyrdness said:

potato_hamster said:

There are no generic characters in TL? According to who exactly? You don't have to create a character that represents yourself. You can create whatever you character you want. I actually am familiar with this game. One Let's player imported a Mii of Waluigi. I guess he never cared about playing as himself? I guess he missed the whole point of the game according to you? He used the Mii creator to create another character. How is that any different than creating a character in Skyrim that looks like Waluigi? Ohh right it isn't. It's just a character creator.

"The entire game is centred on throwing your avatar in antics and interaction" -

This can literally describe any game which allows you to create a character and do anything with that created character. It is utterly meaningless.

"Arguing that's not the draw of the game is like arguing fans of horror games don't buy their games for horror."

I'm sorry, is games that feature Mii avatars now a genre? Ohh it isn't? Huh. I guess that's a pretty terrible analogy. Tomodachi Life is a Life Simulation game. Would you say that the main draw of the sims is playing as characters that are stylzed humans? No. No one really cares about Sims characters. If EA allows you to import your sims character into the latest Madden football game, that isn't going to lead to an increase in sales, because the gameplay is the selling feature of the sims, not the avatar. How about Splatoon avatars? Is the main draw of that game the fact that the avatars in that game look like an anthropomorpic squid/octopusl? Of course not. They buy Splatoon because of the gameplay. No one really cares about Inklings or Octolings. Replace those characters with characters that look completely different but equally appealing and that game would sell just as well and be just as enjoyable to play.

So again, what evidence do you have that the main draw of Tomodachi Life is playing as your Mii any more than the main draw of splatoon is playing as an Inkling, for example?

1- Yes the are no generic characters in TL, that's the game by default it's what the player wants it to be and here's the kicker for you, it's all centred around Miis this is something you can never argue. He imported a Mii, that Mii he imported is to interact with other Miis he has, are you seeing the pattern here? Take your time and don't rush.

2- Seeing as you're grasping at straws and trying hard to take everything out of context, the game is about Miis in a quirky social simulation.

3- Analogy is fine it's just your desperation that's amusing at this point, this was explain in the first point but it's one you're struggling to grasp, Tomodachi Life is a game about Miis and even marketed with Miis as such. Here's the thing about gameplay it's applied to a concept to work and gameplay itself can rely on a number of aspects to be elevated.

For one many RPGs share very similar gameplay especially the turn based types yet are each recieved differently, under your attempted gameplay logic they should all be of equal recption despite having different settings, characters, stories etc... Right? Come off this garbage you're throwing out please it's amusing, different games have different approaches and some are more gameplay dependent then others, TL has simple gameplay but is built around the quirk and social charm of Miis. Gameplay is one part of a machine that is execution, a game can have good gameplay but not be as well recieved because of the overall execution, in TL the concept is a social simulation with Miis that's the main draw of the game and what it's pushed as.

I'm grasping at straws?

The fact that you can import or create generic characters the exact same way as you can in any other game which allows you customize an avatar is somehow unique because that avatar is called a "Mii"? You gotta be joking me.

I create a character in the Sims that looks like Obama. Look Obama is my neighbor. How fun. I can invite Obama to my parties. i can set Obama up with my other neighbors. Obama goes on a date with a sim I created that looks like George Bush. How exciting! Vs - I create a character in Tomodachi life that looks like Obama.  Obama is my neighbor. I can invite Obama over to my parites. ! No wait! This is a Mii specific experience! It's all about the Mii! A Mii is my neighbor! Miis are special!

What?

You can replace the avatars in Tomodachi Life with Microsoft Avatars and it wouldn't change the game in any way! It would play exactly the same. You could do exactly the same with with characters just as custom. The Mii does. not. matter. No one cares whether or not the characters look like Miis or not!

But here is where you lost me. Can you guess where?

"but is built around the quirk and social charm of Miis"

The quirk and social charm of Miis? What quirk and social charm? They literally had zero personalities in any way before this game. They had no voice. They had no quirks. There was literally nothing to distinguish one Mii from the next besides their appearance! They were souless, voiceless avatars that you could customize the look of. That's why when you add or import the character into TL you need to give them a voice, a personality. There is absolutely zero reason why this exactly same game could not be made with literally any other avatar style. None.  What are you getting on with?