Mafia Round 71 - Game Thread - Metal Gear - Mafia Wins!

[outlawauron]

Clyde32 said:

theprof00 said:

My theory is this.
Each one had a kill, but didn't realize how many kills there would be during the night.
A serial killer might think "Ok, so there's the mafia and myself, I just have to avoid attention from them", and then be surprised that there is indeed another killer on the loose.
A vig might think the same
And so would the mafia. 
All vice versa, of course.

Actually I think the reaction is more akin to a mafia. When you are a mafia you expect there to be one kill. If you were a serial killer or a vig you would know that there would be the person you killed as well as the person the mafia killed. One more kill might be a surprise, but not enough for that kind of reaction.

With a game this size, there's no chance there'd be only 1 death with no-scum/vigil/serial killer lynch. The surprise comes from the rather one sided deaths, as I didn't expect 3 people with roles to die. Hence, the surprise.