Mr_No on 19 June 2015
It's all subjective in the end. When Sony's conference ended, I explored many popular gaming sites so I could pick up a consensus. It's not a definitive consensus, but I saw many people agreeing that Sony won E3, with a fair share of detractors. They simply brought surprises to the show; no one expected any of those games, especially in that succession. Uncharted 4 being shown already? Halo 5 and Rise of Tomb Raider were shown before and I didn't complain. As for not accomplishing their promises, people never forget. The Last Guardian being a good example.
In the end, whoever won E3 is subjective. But objectively, Sony did put their best cards on the table. It's not wise to downplay the conference and dismiss it as hype.
