Just like in school. A is best and F is worst. Very simple. I will be honest and fair, despite my console preference. Please remember that these are just my opinions. Here goes!
Microsoft: A-
They delivered a solid show. They had several exclusive games that should please most Xbox owners. Halo 5, Gears 4, New Fable, New Forza etc. The Rare collection is cool for those who like those games. It is a good value for what you get. More Tomb Raider footage and Dark Souls 3.
The one thing that boosted this from a B- was backwards compatibility! That was a big surprise and with hundreds of titles coming, it is a much welcome feature! They also had an interesting show for their hybrid VR/reality device.
Sony: A-
The Last Guardian, Horizon, Street Fighter 5, Dreams, Final Fantasy World, Assassin's Creed, and especially the shocking FF7 remake! Wow, what a show! The surprise factor was high. New footage of No Man's Sky showed off how vast it is. The new Batman footage was creepy, yet interesting.
I feel their Morpheus showing was not detailed enough, and it was highly disappointing that no price cut was made to any of their systems. Otherwise, they would have gotten an A+.
Nintendo: D
Their showing was weaker than I thought. Very few surprises; very few new games period. No price cuts to their overpriced systems. Short show. Very disappointing.
Starfox, Xenoblade X, the new Fire Emblem, and Mario Maker were showed again; however, we have seen plenty of Mario Maker, Fire Emblem, and Xenoblade already. What people wanted to see more of the most was Zelda for Wii U... nothing.
There were a few surprises. Nothing was very exciting in my opinion. A new Zelda for 3DS using an old concept: co op Links. A downgraded Metroid Prime for 3DS. I hope it was my computer screen, or bad footage, because the graphics looked weak. There was a new Paper Mario/regular Mario mix game. It was probably the most interesting concept of the show.
Their was a little more that was so forgettable that I can't remember enough details to describe them. Oh yeah, more Animal Crossing and a weird looking JRPG that didn't interest me a bit. And I'm a JRPG fan.
I was hoping for a true HD Metriod. You know, not Prime, but a more traditional Metroid. Even Prime would have been Ok if it was on Wii U. I wanted more surprises and a price cut to Wii U and New 3DS. I wanted to see new footage of Zelda for Wii U. I just felt let down.
