They won largely off the back of how solid the presentation was, which I take into large consideration when rating conferences. Things like the amount of unnecessary bullshit, the amount of surprises, the amount of innovation, the amount of CG only announcements etc are all important to me when looking at a conference. Sony brought more surprises and bigger surprises than anyone else.
If you want to evaluate the future of the consoles, you are no longer really rating the conferences, however, Sony still had a fairly strong showing (although likely not on the "best conference evar" level). While I don't know which games are making their way to XBO, Sony still showed that they have a large number of multiplatform games releasing as well as some pretty big exclusives such as TLG, Horizon, Uncharted and Dreams.
It was a damn good conference and Sony's lineup is interesting, diverse and innovative.







