A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[Recycle001]

fatslob-:O said:

Recycle001 said:

http://www.vgchartz.com/game/81797/call-of-duty-advanced-warfare/ 

Successful? Yes. Amazing... no. Some of the least successful games are some of the greats. Just saying.

I don't know about you but shouldn't a game that's valued by more people be the better game ? 

Thats a really subjective and general way of speaking. My above example of COD is has so many counter points. Lets take Earthbound for example. People lately have been hating on COD, but it sold more than EB ever did. Does that make COD:AW better than EB? Thats a matter of opinion.

I personally hate Halo. I think its a god aweful game franchise that never once had an original idea. The story is Stargate and the gameplay is Unreal Tournament. Does that make it a bad game? Does it make it better than another game? Thats up to you.

Are you defining value by what it means to a corporation or what it means to the individual or the consumer base as a whole? Overarching and sweeping generalizations are pretty silly imo.

*edit: I've been reading a few threads on VGChartz today, seems like a lot of people are getting salty over next to nothing. Weird.