A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[Wyrdness]

archer9234 said:

I don't get why people always say Zelda isn't a RPG. It means Role Playing Game. Not Role Leveling System Playing Game.

Tbh Zelda is more of a genre of its own, it's an Adventure game that has elements of RPGs and Sand Box genre. It can really fall under any of these but is mainly seen as an Adventure game because character growth (not necessarily leveling) isn't the central part of the experience.