A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[sc94597]

Samus Aran said:

xbx is an action rpg, so strange question lol.

No it's not. Action RPG =/= Real Time RPG. An Action RPG needs 1:1 button/key mapping. Meaning if I press x character performs x-attack. If I press y character performs y-attack. Some action-rpgs do use menus as well (see: Kingdom Hearts) but their main gameplay is through button-maps.