The order's 1886 first review 7,5/10

[sundin13]

tokilamockingbrd said:

Goodnightmoon said:

Most of the reviews are probably going to be worse than the french one, but ok, i get you.

90% + of the impressions on GAF are very positive. In fact I have seen one bad one and I am skepital of him because he said the 1st half was good but the 2nd half was boring, which is the opposite of what EVERYONE else is saying. Linked. The OP has a very well written impression and after page 60 or so you start reading quite a few. But hey if you want to just listen to what reviewers are saying that is your choice as it is your money.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=992687

There have been a good deal of complaints about how the story feels unfinished and leaves loose ends virtually everywhere (including from the OP in follow up posts), or people saying that while the characters are well acted and the writing is good, the story isn't very strong. I find it quite hard to justify a game who's main purpose is delivering a story, that doesn't even really do that remarkably well.