FarleyMcFirefly on 16 February 2015
I'm in the same boat as you. Slasher/gore flicks just gross me out, they aren't scary. But once you see a lot, I find myself rarely getting a good scare these days.
If you haven't, which you probably have, try the original Exorcist.
Annabel was pretty decent.
Silent Hill was kind of scary the first time I saw it, and its soundtrack is great.
1doesnotsimply
