well the GTA 5 review is done by a completely different reviewer.
Other than that I agree that this Arthur Gies guy probably isn't the right guy to review a huge pile of Japanese games.
Vanquish, Bayonetta 2, Killer is Dead and probably a few more.
EDIT: http://www.polygon.com/2014/12/1/7312633/captain-toad-treasure-tracker-review-wii-u
8.5 which is above the Metascore!