The best of the Big Three

[BenKenobi88]

NintendoTogepi said:

Well, it's been a month since SSBB came out so I think it's time for this thread...

We all know the "Big 3" were very hyped and stuff, but which do you think is the best?

Which was the most influential? The most important?

I personally think Super Mario Galaxy wins almost every category, it's a brilliant game, with some of the best game design in years, and it proved that Mario can still be Game of the Year, and that Nintendo can still put out a AAAA game. It's also the first widely accepted "E" Game of the Year in 7 years! Truly innovative, and I think we'll still be talking about it 5 years from now. It's also IMO my favorite game ever. What Super Mario 64 and Sunshine should have been, SMG is the true evolution of 2D Mario.

As for Super Smash Bros. Brawl, I find it very good but, a month later, it's become horribly boring to me. My friends don't like the game, it gets boring fighting against CPUs and the online is unuseable pretty much.

And MP3...I never played it.

Definitely Super Mario Galaxy for the best of the 3 though, in pretty much everyway.

But what do you think? Which is your favorite? Which do you think is the most influential?

 Holy crap, SSBB was definitely the best game out of the "Big 3."

SMG came in close second, because it was definitely a great game...great fun, definitely great polish.

And Brawl's online system is a little shoddy, but it's not quite unplayable...I've had a bunch of online matches with friends as well as random people.  But Brawl was just an epic launch...we played that thing for over a day straight...pretty much non-stop, really.  And I still play the game nearly every day, and my friends love it...it has much more lasting appeal than the other two games since it's multiplayer.