By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
spemanig said:
IIIIITHE1IIIII said:


Where is Fludd in Super Mario Glaxy? Why is there no 8-player option in Mario Party 9? Where are the transformation masks in Skyward Sword? Why are there no two-seated karts in Mario Kart 8?

Answer: Because certain features are only fun once, and by making you revisit them in their original form you will remember them (as well as the games they appeared in) more fondly. This is part of what makes Nintendo's remakes such as Wind Waker HD so highly regarded: People don't want to have another Zelda with a vaster ocean and more islands, they want to revisit how it felt to explore the original ocean the first time. Likewise, people don't want to have another Mario Kart with two-seated karts, because they can just play the original game or hope for a re-release of some sort. Nintendo recognizes this.

The same can't be said about most video game developers who try to make each new iteration in any given franchise outshine its predecessor in every aspect rather than trying to make each new entry unique. This does not only render the older entries dated, forgettable and obsolete, but makes the series as a whole stale.


Pokemon following you was an improvement. Costomizable trainers is an improvement. Seasons were an improvement. Two seated cars SHOULD be an option in Mario Kart. Sea traversial SHOULD be a stable in Zelda. Those aren't features only fun once. Those should be staples that are expanded upon. You're literally lauding Nintendo for making their games worse. Yes, game developers SHOULD be trying to outshine their previous games. And no, that doesn't mean those games can't be unique.


I disagree with you on the Customizable trainers. This is a remake, there is no need to add everything in the game especially when the remake has to refocus on soooo many other things (like contest/secret bases, something XY doesn't have).

I bet trainer customization will return in Z (or watever its called) and future generations. TBH, i kinda knew they wouldn't bring that back, if they added everything, the games wouldn't be finished and we probably still be in gen 5 today :0