Which is the better TPS Game?

[foodfather]

Wright said:

JustThatGamer said:

Gears of War series > Uncharted series

Gears 2 > Gears 1 > UC2 .... > Gears 3 > UC3.... >>> UC1..... >>>> Judgment
(     amazing games        )         ( good games )         (decent)               (shit)

 

We can and should just pretend Judgment didn't happen. 

I never understood why people only consider "good" the third Gears of War. It's my favourite, by far.

Gears 3 suffered from what I like to call Fincher syndrome. (a la Alien 3)

I'm sure there was a good vision for the game, but a combination of pseudo ''artistic merit'' and some truly sloppy and rushed ideas lead to it being the weakest campaign in the series.