"As a sequel to the best action game of the last generation"
Says who, exactly? By comparison's sake, God of War III had a higher metacritic (take it as you will) and more sales, despite being exclusive.
OT: This whole thread is incredibly biased (as are most things but OP didn't even try) We have no idea in what state WD will come in and both games are for two different types of gamers, with "mature" gaming being the middle ground. How about mature gamers just buy both?
EDIT: If you aren't trying to convince us to buy one of the other, why use words like "gimped" and put Bayo 2 on a higher pedestial?








