Sonic: The most overrated game ever?

[AZWification]

curl-6 said:

On topic though, Sonic has never been great.

Even the Genesis entries suffered from the franchise's fundamental problem; when its going fast, it's more a cutscene than a game, and when it slows down, it lacks the tight controls a platformer needs to excel.

I don't really get this complaint.. I can play the Genesis games just fine everytime I want to slowdown! Platforming has never been an issue for me in the 2D games ( the 3D games on the other hand? Yeah.....). :-/