Mr Khan on 21 May 2014
Yes, this is the plot of Dark Empire: Sidious survives the fall, tries to turn Luke (although this happened 6 years after "Return", not 35 or so like episode 7).
It doesn't work because it negates Anakin's sacrifice and diminishes the significance of his entire character arc, and his arc is the first six movies to begin with...
Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.
